Terrible Judging, Follow your own rules freshbrain

sort by: newest oldest
September 23, 2009 at 06:37 pm - by nosedog (15 Posts)
icon

In the vertigo t shirt contest 

You should have included if you put detail in your design than it is going to be overlooked.

Seriously if i knew you were going to skip over entries with alot of detail than i wouldnt have put any effort into my designs.

First place- Cool concept but still not alot of detail put into although i think they did a very good job.

2nd and 3rd - Are you kidding me freshbrain and vertigo are you kidding me?!?

2nd- in the rules for this contest you are supposed to follow the theme of summer technology, so bloody hand print, yeah that totally follows the theme, and there is barely any detail in it at all.

3rd place - This has to be a joke by fresh brain and vertigo, it looks like it was done in ms paint, i have no idea how puzzles relate to technology or summer in anyway what-so-ever and also it says in the rules to design to the demographic (13- 18) and you picked puzzle pieces. The last time i saw a puzzle was when i had to move some antiques into my grandmas basement, and my 13, 14,15,16, and 18 year old cousins walked up to it and said whats this thing and i said i have no idea it mustve been a picture that was so old that it shattered and nobody wanted to put it back together again becuase thats boring than we all went and did stuff that actually was within our demographic like listen to music, go on the computer, ride a bike, build robots. But 1 thing is for sure that none of us played with a puzzel.

 In my opinion 2nd place and 3rd place were either rigged, or chosen by vertigo and freshbrain so they could save money in printing by choosing the t shirts with the least design possible.

and i hope all the people on here who actually put effort into their designs feel the same way.

The judging for this is terrible, follow your own rules vertigo and dont give us ones that will make us lose apparently.

Essentially 1st place was binary code, which is essentially numbers. All they needed to do was type not alot of detail or work.

2nd place was a bloody hand print which was probably just a brush set, has nothing to do with the theme or technique or even creativity yet it placed second.

3rd place was 2 puzzle pieces drawn in ms paint, so that fails to meet the demographic of 13-18 unless every person my age i know is just a human oddity and for some reason we dont play with puzzles. that doesnt meet the theme, its terrible put together it is a mess no technique nothing.

Dont mislead me freshbrain if you had told me i would have put no effort into my design and probably won, now people who looks like they didnt even try get this accomplishment and all of us who actually put in alot of work are sitting her like, wtf freshbrain wtf.

Im not trying to be mean to the entries that i talked about this is in no way torwards your designs but torwards freshbrain and vertigos judging, i feel they did a terrible job and it seems like freshbrain and and vertigo for lack of a better phrase are being corporate harlets and trying to save money by picking designs with no detail so they dont have to spend any money to print them, and by doing this they are screwing over people who worked hard becuase they really wanted to win this becuase maybe they plan on making a living off of this or going to college for this and this could have been something really nice to have on a resume.

thanks for wasting my time fresh brain.